To the main site
To the main site

Catalog

Offers

Interviews

Magazine

Forum
To the main site Search/map of the site Contact us Russian version

Online-Interview

Subari Sozar, Georgia 02.25.2005, 14:00
Georgian Public Defender and the new State Ombudsman, appointed to this position in August 2004. Formerly worked as human rights activist at Georgian NGO Liberty Institute and was a correspondent with Radio Liberty in Tbilisi. He is one of the founding fathers of the Fair Elections Foundation.
Correspondernt:

Question N 1 [time = 25.02.2005 12:44:17 (MSK)] [from Amirov L.Sh.(azerbayjan)]
Good afternoon, Mr. Ombudsman.
Do forgive me for the rather awkward questions Why were you so tense, when you noticed that the Deputy Chairman of the Supreme Court Valerjy Khrustal, exceeded his authority, but no declaration of principle has been made by you regarding the total violation of rights of the Azerbaijanian population in Georgia.

Answer [time: 25.02.2005 16:15:34 (MSK)]
Protection of the rights of ethnic minorities is one of the priorities for me. Our regional office Kvemo Kartli will transfered from Marneuli ( centre of the district, densely populated by Azerbaijanians)to Rustavi within the nearest week. I believe there is dire necessity of such an act, due to the problems existing in the region. After the fatal incident on Kulari I visited the place of the crime twice. During my second visit I was accompanied by Azerbaihjanian ombudsman Elmira Suleymanova. Regarding the term “total violation” of the rights of the Azerbaijanian population, they are not violated to greater extent than those of the other citizens of Georgia, Georgians included. The fact that the majority of Kvemo Kartli residents, Azerbaijanis, just as Armenians, residing in Javakheti, do not speak Georgian, is exceptional. The given fact prevents civic integration of the abovementioned ethnic groups, turning into a major obstacle on their way to carve their career. Former government never dwelt on the existing problem, while the present authorities are developing serious plans for the resolution of the problem.

Question: N 2 [time=25.02.2005 12:48:46 (MSK)] [from Amirov L.Sh.(Azerbaijan)]
How do you assess, the use of fire arms in Kulari village of Marneuli region or Marneuli check point? We want to hear your opinion, not as ombudsman, but as the citizen of the neighbouring state, which is a strategic partner of Azerbaijan.

Answer: [time: 25.02.2005 16:22:02(MSK)]
The given criminal act is a direct result of the problems, which have long been accumulating in the region. In the meantime the law enforcement bodies are doing their best to detain the criminal. The case is connected directly with the unfair distribution of land. Present authorities are trying to redistribute land fairly and legally. As for the Gardabani case , the cases of smuggling have been uncovered there, and the government must take corresponding measures.

Questtion N 3 [time=25.02.2005 12:53:26(MSK)] [from Agajyan E.A (Azerbaijan)]
This id Elchin Agajanov “Express” newspaper. Good afternoon, Mr. Subari.
Provided that you yourself were a correspondent in the recent pas, we believe that your answers will be more sincere than those of the officials. We’d like to know statistics for the violation of Human Rights in comparison with Shevardnadze regime. Thank you in advance.

Answer: [time: 25.02.2005 14:48:00(MSK)]<
Facts of illegal detention and violence by the police have increased in the previous year. However its noteworthy that in the beginning of current year the situation has improved notably. Matters have also improved regarding the freedom of religion. Complains of mass dismissals from the jobs have become common. The problem arose for the global restructuring of all state structures.

Question N 4 [time-25.02.2005 13:01:02(MSK)] [from Agajyan E.A.(Azerbaijan)
There are about 85 cafes and restaurants operated by the businessmen of Georgian nationality. Meeting the people, chatting jovially in Georgian has become quite a common scene in Baku. I have been to many places in Tbilisi and failed to meet a single person speaking in Azerbaijanian, despite the fact that there more Azreis reside in Tbilisi, than there are Georgians in Baku, let alone owners of any kind of private facility, who would have confessed to being Azerbaijanian. How could all this be interpretted? It certainly could not be ascribed to idleness, as Azrbaijanians from Borchalo, possess numerous commercial facilities in Baku. Are similar issues under your supervision. Issues of national minorities are regarded by our ombudsman as a matter of concern.

Answer: [time:25.02.2005 15:16:54(MSK)]
I love to visit Azernbaijanian restaurants in Tbilisi, they make delicious Kebab.As for Azerbaijanian language, there I disagree with you entirely, I am absolutely convinced that the problem is non existent. Active Mosques, which I usually visit on religious festivals are good example for this. The problem lies in entirely different matter, Azerbaijanians residing in Kvemo Kartli speak no other language apart frpm Azarbaijanian, Now let’s consider the issue of the Georgians residing in Azerbaijan, Saingilo population has multiple complains regarding the violation of their, even elementary rights, namely, there does not exist a single shop in the region belonging to Georgians. Besides, they complain about the fact that they are not allowed to reestablish their Georgian family names, changed in Soviet times into Azerbaijanian. By the way such problem does not exist in Kvemo Kartli.

Question N 5 [time=25.02.2005 13:06:28(Msk) [from Agajan E.A (Azerbaijan)]
Tamaz Bakuradze was detained in Batumi during the rule of Aslan Abashidze, on the charges of financial transgressions and taking advantage of his position. I remember you visited him in prison in September last year. What was the end of the episode? Had his detention political reasons or was he proved guilty of criminal activities?

Answer [time:25.02.2005 15:27:12(MSK)].
I visited Tamaz Bakuridze in prison. The case is still being investigated. We possess all the materials of the investigation, but we can not interfere into the investigation. Thus we have no legal right to determine whether Tamaz Bakuridze is guilty or not. The court refused to let him out on bail. In my opinion civil rights have not been violated in the case of Bakuridze.

Question N 6 [time=25.02.2005 13:13:59(MSK)] [from Hasimov A.A. (others)]
Russian news papers published the information on the detention of Giorgi Zhvania, staff member of Eastern regional Customs Service, for culpable negligence. To make my question clear I would like to add that the abovementioned official (detainee), according to the higher officials, has not been applying penal sanctions during the registration procedure of the cars at the customs office, inflicting thus losses upon the state. Is it possible that all culpable custom officers serve on the Azerbaijan border? Besides, is the officer’s family name just a coincidence or the relations of the deceased Prime Minister are being “ousted” one after another? Do forgive my lack of tact, it’s just my profession....

Answer: [time:25.02.2005 15:32:11(MSK) ]
I must confess, it is for the first time I hear about the arrest of Zhvania. No complains have been submitted into my office regarding the given case. Whether the activities were criminal or not will be determined by the court. Nor do I possess any information, whether the arrested person is related to the Prime Minister.

Question N 7 [time=25.02.2005 13:54:43(MSK)] [from Kamavosyan O.A. (Armenia)]
Good afternoon Mr. Subari. This is Ofelia Kamavosyan of Information Agency “Armenpress”.
Could you please tell us about the future co-operation between the Ombudsmen of our region.

Answer: [time: 25.02.2005 15:49:17(MSK)]
I have already been on a visit to Armeniain order to share the experience. A joint seminar is due to take place in Tbilisi in March, which will be attended by both Armenian and Azerbaijanian representatives. In May our representatives will be visiting Armenia to attend a seminar regarding sddresing the issue of tollerance. As for other aspects of co-operation, the cases of sending complaints from Azerbaijan or Armenia over the matter of violation of the rights of the citizens of their countries on the territory of Georgia are rather frequent. We consider each of the concrete cases.. Similar requests are submitted by Georgia for the protection of the rights of her citizenson the territories of Armenia or Azerbaijan. Namely, quite recently, when the citizen of Georgia of Azerbaijanian nationality was detained in Armenia, Armenian Ombudsman, Larisa Alaverdyan, supported the transfer of the detainee to Georgia.

Question N 8 [time=25.02.2005 13:58:59(MSK)] [from Stepanyan L.V.(Armenia)
Liana Stepanyan from the newspaper “ Repubic of Armenia”.
How ombudsmen and his staff is appointed in Georgia?

Answer: [time:25.02.2005 16:01:50(MSK)]
Ombudsman Candidate is named either by the president or a group of MPs. In either cases the candidate should be approved by the Parliament. The staff is formed by the Ombudsman. Recently we began the formation of a new staff on the competition basis.

Question N 9 [time=25.02.2005 14:04:21(MSK)] {from Stepanyan L.V.(Armenia)]
Are there representations of the ombudsman in the regions of Georgia?, How many people a day do you receive, and what are the issues addressed?

Answer [time:25:02.2005 16:07::(MSK)]
There are representations in several regions, namely Kvemo Kartli and Samtskhe – Javakheti. In the beginning of my work about 250 appeals used to be submitted daily, now 5 – 7 appeals daily.
Thank you for interesting questions.


About  Memorandum
Login: 
Password: 
Registration
Articles market
Offers of Journalists:
 .
...
Mtvarelishvili N.V
For ...
Barseghyan A.R
...
Mgebrishvili K.T
...
Martirosyan S.V
...
Offers of publishers:

...

...

1. ...
"AZG"
1. ...
Center "Region"
We ...
Announcement
Questions are accepted only from the registered journalists
Last Online Interviews
Usupashvili David, Georgia
Kharatyan Hranush , Armenia
Sikharulidze Vasil, Georgia
Shahgeldyan Mger, Armenia
Berdzenishvili Levan, Georgia
Alaverdyan Larisa, Armenia
Mammadov Novruz, Azerbaijan
Suleymanova Elmira
Subari Sozar, Georgia
Manoyan Giro, Armenia
Papava Vladimer, Georgia
Chiaberashvili Zurab, Georgia
Guluzadeh Vafa, Azerbaijan
Interviews archive
A B C D E F J H I J K L M
N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

South Caucasus: Legal advice

Advicer:Khetaguri George (Georgia)
Questions & answers
Advicer:Rshtuni Narine (Armenia)
Questions & answers
Advicer:Hadjibeyli Annagi Bahadur oglu
Questions & answers


The site is created at support of the Program on Cooperation on Southern Caucasus of Eurasia Foundation

Design and hosting — «Contact Company», Dubna.