To the main site
To the main site

Catalog

Offers

Interviews

Magazine

Forum
To the main site Search/map of the site Contact us Russian version

Online-Interview

Manoyan Giro, Armenia 02.15.2005
Armenian Revolutionary Federation International Secretary. Was born in Lebanon. In 1976 he moved to Canada. Has got University degree in Political Science. From 1991 to 1999 was the editor of the newspaper "Horizon”. Since 1999 he lives in Armenia.
Correspondernt:

Question N1 Gurgenidze P.S. (Georgia) Mr. Kiro Manoyan, let me ask you the first question. Many think that including the countries of South Caucasus in the initiative of the European Union-European Neighbourhood Policy is the achievement of our countries and a step towards Europe. However, there are sceptics who consider that same initiative as closing the gates of the European Union to countries when they simultaneously attempt to change authoritarian political systems to democratic ones. How do you comment on this?

Answer. It must be said that including countries especially those of the South Caucasus is progress and a step towards Europe. The fact that the countries of the South Caucasus were included into this program later than the rest testifies that integration is the result of attempts by these countries. For those countries which are part of other European structures and now take part in this program, it is really a step ahead on the way of European integration, which is impossible to pass without democratisation.

Question N2 Salmanov H.Y. (Azerbaijan) Good afternoon, I am Hyugug Salmanov. Now I represent the “Express” newspaper. Last year from July to December, Armenia was officially campaigning among countries of the European Union with the aim of settling relations with Turkey. On the other hand, though your party is a member of ruling coalition, it insists that Turkey is obliged to accept the wrong committed against the Armenian citizens of Turkey during the First World War and compensate Armenia with moral and material damages. Does this mean that you have disagreements in the aforementioned issue?

Answer. Membership of Turkey in the European Union demands the democratisation of that country and the acceptance by Turkey of European values. However, a country that is avoiding its past, however dark, can’t be considered Europeanized. Accordingly, our minimum demand is that Turkey accepts the fact of Genocide of the Armenians before entering the European Union. In this process we don’t have disagreements just with the ruling coalition but also with the political circles of Armenia. Recognition of Genocide brings with it the question of compensation which can later be negotiated.

Question N3 Amirova L. Sh. (Azerbaijan) Amirova Leyla from the “Azerbaijani news” newspaper. Good afternoon. The European Commission presented a report on Turkey meeting the so called “Copenhagen criteria” last autumn. In December, a decision was made with regards to the timescale for starting negotiations on Turkey’s accession to the European Union. Now Turkey is the only country in the region with the official status of a candidate for membership of the European Union. What you think about the fact that European Union has “approached” to Armenia.

Answer. First of all, on 17 December the issue of membership of Turkey into the European Union was not decided but rather, the issue of the timescale for starting negotiations with Turkey for membership was. In that same decision it was also mentioned that another result of negotiations might be that Turkey will not join the European Union. In other words, this decision doesn’t guarantee the membership of Turkey into the European Union and the desire by our northern neighbour to become a member can allow Armenia to border the EU even without Turkey’s membership.

Question N4 Guliyeva G.M. (Azerbaijan) Good afternoon, I am the independent correspondent, Gyulnaz Guliyeva. You have said on more than one occasion that “until there is a perception of Nagorno Karabagh, Armenia and liberated territories as three different concepts, the concessionary mood of the Armenian side is obvious.” Is this your position or an official one that is not expressed at the highest levels?

Answer. Concerning the first part of your question, yes, this corresponds to the official position of Armenia – that Nagorno Karabagh, Armenia and the liberated territories are different. This position has often been expressed by officials in Armenia. As for the second part of the quote, it is possible that someone came to that opinion but I have never made that sort of announcement. According to the official position, these territories were taken differently and it is natural that there is a difference between liberated territories especially when it is said that Nagorno Karabagh can’t be an enclave and to settle the conflict it must have a secure and large border with Armenia. From our point of view and from the point of view of our party Nagorno Karabagh Republic must include all liberated territories. The concept of “Nagorno Karabagh” is connected with Stalin and these territories are historically Armenian and strategically important to Armenia.

Question N5 Guliyeva G.M. (Azerbaijan) The international mission headed by the co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk group found out and is investigating cases of a settlement of Karabagh by Armenians. At the end of the month the report will be published. What positive things do you see in these new settlements as the head of the Bureau “Hay dat?”

Answer. You say that the report will be published at the end of the month and yet you are already speaking about the content of that report. Either you do tell not the truth or the mission provided you with that information which calls into question the objectivity of that mission. People who live in Karabagh are mainly the inhabitants of the regions which are occupied by Azerbaijan. Unfortunately, there is no Armenian state program to settle these regions with Armenians which could have really have had a positive result. In the Shahumyan and Martakert regions occupied by Azerbaijan, your country is officially realising a program of resettlement which has resulted in a large concentration of Azerbaijanis there. These territories were not visited by the mission and I am not talking about the ethnic cleansing of Armenians from Karabagh and Nakhichevan by Azerbaijan which was realised during decades.

Question N6 Amirova L.Sh. (Azerbaijan) After the change of the situation in the Ukraine in favour of the “Euro Atlantic alliance” it has become clear that Russia can only delay the process of retreating from the South Caucasus. How will Armenians behave in that case according to “Hay dat” and “Dashnaktsutyuan”?

Answer. The integration of Armenia into the “Euro Atlantic alliance” is going on at the same speed as the other countries of South Caucasus. What can guarantee the security of Armenia in case of the situation you described? Dashnaktsutyuan has never hoped for international forces and that’s why it has the objective of developing a powerful Armenian state which will be the main guarantee for our own security. Armenia and Russia are strategic allies and Russian forces are here at the request of Armenia.

Question N7 Amirova L.Sh. (Azerbaijan) You were against sending an Armenian contingent to Iraq and that is also the position of your party “Dashnaktsutyun.” Is this connected only with the fact that 15.000 Armenians live in Iraq?

Answer. Not only in Iraq but in all the Near East are people who experienced Genocide and were accepted by Arabic nations who consider the foreign forces in Iraq as occupational. The position of Dashnaktsutyun in this issue is similar to the position of those European states who are also allies of the USA which didn’t send troops to Iraq.

Question N8 Ter-Sahakyan K.G.(Armenia) Karine Ter-Sahakyan, ”Repulic of Armenia.” Dear Mr. Manoyan, Mehmed Ali Briand thinks that Turkey must initiate its own propaganda against the fact of the Genocide of Armenians. What must we be ready for in case of contra-propaganda?

Answer. The words of Mehmed Ali Briand concerned the fact that until now the position of official Turkish circles on denying the Armenian Genocide hasn’t given any results. Accordingly, it is necessary to take another approach to the issue. For Armenians there is no need for contra-propaganda because our position is based on historical truth. Everyone in the world apart from state circles of Turkey and their allies acknowledge this historical fact. It is another issue that because of political and economic reasons they haven’t touch upon the question of recognising the Genocide.

Question N9 Bukiya S.S.(Georgia) Good afternoon. Newspaper “24 hours.” I have a short question. Is there a representation of the Dashnaktsutyun party in the region of Samtskhe-Javakheti and if so, what activities do the dashnaks conduct there?

Answer. Our party in Samtskhe-Javakheti and generally in Georgia has no representation, even though the party was established in Tbilisi in 1890. In Armenian–Georgian relationships Samtskhe-Javakheti is the weakest link and Dashnaktsutyun is sure that with mutual Armenian–Georgian efforts this region can be the strongest link in our relations. If Georgia is really on the way of European integration it must secure the existence and development of its national minorities. Current problems which exist in Samtskhe-Javakheti have not only a social-economic character but also are the result of the policy of the previous government. The current government of Georgia has opportunity to conduct another in terms of a constructive policy towards national minorities and, like Armenians say in Samtskhe-Javakheti, integration does not mean amalgamation.

Question N9 Bukiya S.S. (Georgia) What relationship has “Dashnaktsutyun” with the social movement “Djavakhk” in Samtskhe-Javakheti?

Answer. It must be said that the movement “Djavakhk” which existed under Gamsakhurdiya, does not exist now. And Dashnaktsutyun as a pan Armenian organisation contributes to the protection of the rights of Armenians who live all over the world. For this you don’t need to have direct contact with this or that organisation. Dashnaktsutyun knows that the mood spread in Georgia about the party is not so positive and that’s why the party prefers to react to activities in Javakheti and take part in the works of Javaakheti organisations not in a direct but an indirect way. The functioning of Dashnaktsutyun in Georgia can be considered after there is objective information about the party there. In Soviet Armenia Dashnaktsutyun was functioning until 1931 when for the sake of security there was a decision of surrender. Dashnaktsutyun always prefers the security of Armenians wherever they live.

Question N11 Martirosyan S.V.(Armenia) Good afternoon, Mr. Manoyan. I have two connected questions. How do you consider the dynamics of Armenian-Iranian relations and what are the consequences for the region, and in particular Armenia, of any military action of the USA against Iran?

Answer. Dashnaktsutyun considers Armenian-Iranian relations as being very important and is interested in the territorial integrity of Iran. From this point of view we are very worried about the possible actions of the USA or other countries against Iran. In this issue the approaches of our party are the same as a number of European states which are also allies of the USA.

Question N12 Bukiya S.S.(Georgia) What influence does Dashnaktsutyun have on Armenian politics today?

Answer. The Dashnaktsutyun Party is the only one which functions both in Armenia and the Diaspora and directly influences politics in Armenia. Before independence, Armenian politics was divided into two camps. Together with Soviet Armenia or with Dashnaktsutyun which was considered the bearer of the idea of independence for Armenia and more an organisation than a party. After independence, the whole nation became the bearer of the idea of independence which on one hand speaks about the victory of the ideas of Dashnaktsutyun, and on the other, that Dashnaktsutyun is considered a party which is functioning together with other parties of Armenia.

Question N13 Bukiya S.S. (Georgia) Because of fight against terrorism, Russia closed their border with Georgia for a long time which didn’t affect Georgia so much but did affect neighbouring Armenia which is its strategic partner in the Caucasus. Russian officials announced then that “Armenia will understand us.” Do Armenians understand Russia and in general, what is the Russian –Armenia strategic partnership worth?

Answer. Frankly speaking, in Armenia sometimes, certain actions by Russia are not understood, especially those concerning the relations with Azerbaijan and Turkey. Here people hope that Armenia will be better understood in Russia, that Armenia is an independent state and that the Armenian-Russian strategic partnership is between two independent and equal states. However much this partnership is necessary for Armenia as much it is for Russia, the circles you mentioned seem to have difficulty in perceiving these realities. I thank everyone for their questions.


About  Memorandum
Login: 
Password: 
Registration
Articles market
Offers of Journalists:
 .
I ...
Mtvarelishvili N.V
I ...
 .
...
Mtvarelishvili N.V
For ...
Barseghyan A.R
...
Offers of publishers:

...

...

1. ...
"AZG"
1. ...
Center "Region"
We ...
Announcement
Questions are accepted only from the registered journalists
Last Online Interviews
Shota Utiashvili, Georgia
Tigran Torosyan
David Zurabishvili, Georgia
Salome Zurabishvili, Georgia
Nikoloz Rurua, Georgia
Nodar Ladaria, Georgia
Gigi Tevzadze, Georgia
Kharatyan Hranush , Armenia
Guluzadeh Vafa, Azerbaijan
Mammadov Novruz, Azerbaijan
Sikharulidze Vasil, Georgia
Usupashvili David, Georgia
Shahgeldyan Mger, Armenia
Berdzenishvili Levan, Georgia
Alaverdyan Larisa, Armenia
Suleymanova Elmira
Subari Sozar, Georgia
Manoyan Giro, Armenia
Papava Vladimer, Georgia
Chiaberashvili Zurab, Georgia
Interviews archive
A B C D E F J H I J K L M
N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

South Caucasus: Legal advice

Advicer:Khetaguri George (Georgia)
Questions & answers
Advicer:Rshtuni Narine (Armenia)
Questions & answers
Advicer:Hadjibeyli Annagi Bahadur oglu
Questions & answers


The site is created at support of the Program on Cooperation on Southern Caucasus of Eurasia Foundation

Design and hosting — «Contact Company», Dubna.