To the main site
To the main site

Participants

Orders

Interviews

Magazine

Discussion
To the main site Search/map of the site Contact us Russian version

Online-Interview
Manoyan Giro, Armenia 18.09.2007

Armenian Revolutionary Federation International Secretary. Was born in Lebanon. In 1976 he moved to Canada. Has got University degree in Political Science. From 1991 to 1999 was the editor of the newspaper "Horizon”. Since 1999 he lives in Armenia.

[This publication has been produced with the assistance of the European Union. The contents of this publication is the sole responsibility of Caucasus Institute for Peace, Democracy and Development and can in no way be taken to reflect the views of the European Union.] Correspondernt:


Question N 1 [time=14.09.2007 16:16:14(MSK)] [from Gurgenidze P.S.(Georgia)]
Hello, Mr. Manoyan. Our reporters are ready to ask you their questions.

Question N 2 [time=18.09.2007 12:43:43(MSK)] [from A reporter from the newspaper Samkhretis Karibche (Samtskhe-Javakheti), Nino Narimanishvili. (Georgia)]
Good afternoon, Mr. Manoyan. I am interested in whether the platform of your party has envisaged activities in the region of Samtskhe-Javakheti?

Answer [time:18.09.2007 13:07:17(MSK)]
I greet all the journalists here. Our party does not realize any activities in the region of Samtskhe-Javakheti, but we do realize some activities for the Armenians in Samtskhe-Javakheti in the Diaspora. Mostly, we assist to bring the opinions of the residents of Samtskhe-Javakheti to the international community, and especially to the European and American social and political circles. There are some organizations in the Diaspora which are also registered in Georgia. For example, the Union of Aid for Armenians the central office of which is in the USA and which realizes humanitarian activities for the residents of Samtskhe-Javakheti.

Question N 3 [time=18.09.2007 12:48:41(MSK)] [from Martirosyan G.V.(Armenia)]
Hello, dear Mr. Manoyan! I am Gohar Martirosyan, a correspondent from the Armenian TV station Yerkir Media. I would like to know how satisfied you are with the steps undertaken by the Georgian government to improve the living conditions and to intensify the integration of the Armenians living in Georgia into the life of the country?

Answer [time:18.09.2007 13:22:25(MSK)]
Not only have we remained unsatisfied, but we are also concerned with the policy which is being led by the Georgian powers not only towards the residents of Georgia who have Armenian background, but also towards other ethnic minorities from the viewpoint of their integration into the social and political life of the country. It is understandable that all the citizens of the country must know the state language of the country, and instead of undertaking work in that direction, the state fires officials and people, occupying various positions in various spheres, who do not know Georgian. The best way of teaching the representatives of ethnic minorities the state language is the attention paid to the native tongue of these ethnic minorities in order for the latters to feel certain that the aim targeted at by the state is their integration rather than their assimilation. When joining the Council of Europe, Georgia made a series of commitments regarding the cultural and linguistic rights of the ethnic minorities. However, it has not only failed to accomplish these commitments so far, but on the contrary, the situation has even more aggravated, for judges, doctors, headmasters and school teachers who did not know Georgian were fired. And the Akhaltsikhe example, where Armenians do know Georgian, but they fail to receive positions, speaks of the fact that the lack of knowledge of Georgian is an excuse for depriving people of thier jobs rather than a real cause.

Question N 4 [time=18.09.2007 12:48:54(MSK)] [from Bartkulashvili A.G.(Azerbaijan)]
Hello, Mr. Manoyan. Recently the leader of the Parliamentary bloc ARF Dashnaktsutyun Hrayr Karapetyan provoked a discussion on the topic What Is Better – an Independent Nagorno Karabakh or Its Annexation among the political beau monde of Armenia. What can you say about this? Thanks. RUKH – Journalists' Protection Committee in Azerbaijan

Answer [time:18.09.2007 13:34:48(MSK)]
Even though the Karabakh issue is not an issue dealing with ethnic minorities, and correspondingly, is a deviation from the topic of the current interview, I will answer your question. Karabakh was annexed to Azerbaijan against the will of its residents by the decision of Stalin&Co. during the Soviet years, and this decision has lost its validity after the collapse of the Soviet Union. What difference does it make to Azerbaijan whether Karabakh will be part of Armenia or an independent state? In 1988 the movement in Karabakh started for the sake of its joining Armenia, and in 1991 the Republic of Karabakh was proclaimed from tactical considerations. The strategic aim of our party which consists in Karabakh’s joining Armenia has never changed. We can speak on around the issues of the Karabakh conflict but in another interview, specifically devoted to this very topic.

Question N 5 [time=18.09.2007 13:07:22(MSK)] [from Sevil Sharif (Azerbaijan)]
Hello, Mr. Manoyan! How does the Dashnaktsutyun party currently influence the social and political processes under way in Armenia and Georgia? How is this influence manifest and how weak or strong is it? Female Journalists’ Association of Azerbaijan

Answer [time:18.09.2007 13:46:12(MSK)]
In Armenia the Dashnaktsutyun Party is a functioning party represented in the National Assembly of Armenia – in the Parliament, and also represented in the government during the last few years. The perspective of our party is presented to the people during the elections, in the Parliament, through mass media and so on. And the people in their turn determine their attitude to Dashnaktsutyun. Sometimes it so happens that other political forces also make certain steps having adopted the positions and approaches of our party. For example, this was the case about the issue of raising pensions in Armenia. As for Georgia, Dashnaktsutyun does not function there; however, it does maintain connections with the Georgian governmental and political circles and is trying to pass on its perspective to them. Here there is the issue of historical mistrust which needs to be overcome, thus intensifying sincere dialogue between the parties.

Question N 6 [time=18.09.2007 13:10:11(MSK)] [from Mair Bayramov, a free-lance reporter (Azerbaijan)]
Hello! Politics is often called the policy of lying. Do you think that disputes still make a sense if the truth about the Nagorno Karabakh is spoken all the time? Thanks.

Answer [time:18.09.2007 13:50:44(MSK)]
The truth cannot be of various kinds and there cannot be a number of it. The only truth should be accepted for security and stability in our region, for the prosperous future of our generations. This truth consists in the fact that Karabakh has never been part of independent Azerbaijan.

Question N 7 [time=18.09.2007 13:16:30(MSK)] [from Elza Tsiklauri, The Newspaper Rezonansi, Tbilisi (Georgia)]
How do you evaluate the situation of the Armenian Diaspora in Abkhazia? What do you think brought about last year’s events in Abkhazia – the explosion in the territory of the Armenian school in Sukhumi and the dissemination of fliers of anti-Armenian content?

Answer [time:18.09.2007 13:57:09(MSK)]
In Abkhazia, too, where by the law the President of the country can become only an Abkhazian, Armenians encounter the problem of the protection of their civil rights. As for the incidents you mentioned, they seem to have been carried out by those forces which are trying to drive a wedge between Armenians and Abkhazians. Such a situation will not contribute to the settlement of the Georgian and Abkhazian mutual relations.

Question N 8 [time=18.09.2007 13:32:32(MSK)] [from Asatryan N.G. (Armenia)]
Hello, dear Mr. Manoyan! I am Nazeli Asatryan, a correspondent from ArmenPress. I wonder what assistance, do you think, Armenia can provide for the solution of the problems of Javakhq Armenians?

Answer [time:18.09.2007 14:12:22(MSK)]
Armenia, jointly with the Georgian authorities, can create more favorable social, economic, cultural and educational conditions. Armenia has always officially announced this and of its readiness, however, the Georgian side did not always react to such suggestions. For example, with joint efforts Armenians and Georgians may work out a program of social, economic, cultural and educational development, in the implementation of which the Armenian and Georgian states, as well as the Armenian Diaspora, will take part. Such a caring attitude towards Samtskhe-Javakheti on the part of the Armenian and Georgian states may only contribute to the intensification of Armenian and Georgian relations. As for the second part of the question, I have already and to some extent answered it in my previous responses during this interview, however, I would like to add that satisfactory knowledge of the state language is not a matter of only a couple of months, and a little more time is needed for this knowledge to become real. At the same time, it is necessary to give the Armenian language the status of regional language in Samtskhe-Javakheti which would be perfectly in line with the commitments made by Georgia before international organizations and does not differ from those suggestions which Georgia has made to South Ossetia. I hope that during their at the end of last week Presidents Sahakashvili and Kocharyan discussed these issues, too.

Question N 9 [time=18.09.2007 13:32:44(MSK)] [from Raghim Huseinzade, a reporter (Azerbaijan)]
Hello! Does the Dashnaktsutyun Party see any difference between terror acts and patriotism? Thanks.

Answer [time:18.09.2007 14:16:34(MSK)]
Dashnktsutyun condemns terrorism, but a national liberation movement is not considered terrorism. In the first passage of the Human Rights Charter of the UNO it is mentioned that the human rights should be respected. There should not be created a situation when a human being will have to resort to other means for the sake of the protection of his/her rights.

Question N 10 [time=18.09.2007 13:37:54(MSK)] [from Irakli Chikhladze, an independent reporter (Georgia)]
What is your standpoint about the issue of the repatriation of deported Meskhetins? It is common knowledge that the new law on repatriation envisages their return to the motherland starting from next year.

Answer [time:18.09.2007 14:29:35(MSK)]
The issue of the return of Turk-Meskhetins into Georgia does not directly have to do with Armenians. Firstly, because according to the law passed in Georgia they will return to Georgia in general and not necessarily to Samtskhe-Javakheti. And the places where they used to live previously are now occupied by Georgians and not Armenians. We think that the announcements by Georgian political figures according to which it is Armenians who hinder the return of Turk-Meskhetins are incorrect. At the same time, the sincerity of Georgian power about this issue should be treated with some reservation, for we see that Georgian authorities do not demonstrate the appropriate and necessary care towards the ethnic minorities already residing in Georgia.

Question N 11 [time=18.09.2007 13:38:36(MSK)] [from Bartkulashvili A.G.(Azerbaijan)]
Mr. Manoyan! How are the chances and the participation of the Dashnaktsutyun Party assessed for the coming presidential elections? RUKH – Journalists’ Protection Committee

Answer [time:18.09.2007 14:36:33(MSK)]
We highly estimate the possibility of our party’s victory in the Presidential elections of the RA. We hope that the people will correctly evaluate the political situation and for the formation of balanced power in the country will elect the candidate nominated by Dashnaktsutyun for the post of the President and not the candidate from the Parliamentary majority.

Question N 12 [time=18.09.2007 13:42:13(MSK)] [from Nino Narimanishvili, The Samkhretis Karibche, Samtskhe-Javakheti (Georgia)]
What do you think of those projects which are meant to be implemented in Samtskhe-Javakheti – Kars – Akhalkalaki – Baku, Millennium and others? How can they influence Georgian and Armenian relations? What is your party’s standpoint on these projects? Will they serve, in your opinion, the development of the region?

Answer [time:18.09.2007 14:46:06(MSK)]
Both projects you mentioned are different in their essence. The program Millennium Challenges pursues the goal of integrating Samtskhe-Javakheti into Georgia and into the whole of the South Caucasus in general. And Kars – Akhalkalaki – Baku is a program directed towards isolating Armenia. From this perspective we think positively of the Millennium Challenges Program and we treat the project Kars – Akhalkalaki – Baku with some reservation. In both programs the fact that the local Armenian population does not partake in the construction work, just as in the case of Baku-Jeyhan, makes one suspect that the local population will not gain much from these programs. At least we are convinced that there may be a project on the integration of Samtskhe-Javakheti into Georgia which may be implemented through joint Armenian and Georgian efforts and once again with the aid of international funds, for some balance in political goals pursued by the railroad Kars – Akhalkalaki.

Question N 13 [time=18.09.2007 13:52:45(MSK)] [from Irakli Chikhladze, an independent reporter (Georgia)]
Why doesn’t Karabakh take an active part in the meetings and various events of similarly unacknowledged territories in the post-Soviet space? (Abkhazia, South Ossetia, Pridnestrovye)

Answer [time:18.09.2007 14:51:44(MSK)]
The Kaharbakh issue is inherently unique, not only in comparison with other conflicts in the post-Soviet space. There are no other external political powers in the Karabakh issue due to which and because of which this conflict continues. As a state, Karabakh does meet international requirements and standards, and there is no need to hazard this achievement.

Question N 14 [time=18.09.2007 13:54:05(MSK)] [from Elza Tsiklauri, The Rezonanzi (Georgia)]
Lately an opinion was voiced in Armenia on opening an Armenian University in Akhalkalaki. Who, do you think, will finance this undertaking?

Answer [time:18.09.2007 15:03:07(MSK)]
The issue of the foundation of a joint Armenian and Georgian University in Samtskhe-Javakheti is not a new one and comes from the Armenian population in the region. During the past few years the attempts of the Georgian authorities to establish branches and affiliates of Georgian Universities in Samtskhe-Javakheti, the goal of which was to provide an opportunity for the local population to study at a Georgian University, failed, and today these affiliates have already closed down. Many young Armenians from Samtskhe-Javakheti study at Universities in Armenia as a result of which they continue to fail to know and to master the Georgian language. The existence of a joint university would have guaranteed that the Armenian youth would receive higher education right there and as a result would know the state language and would be ready to integrate into the cultural, social and political life of Georgia. Of course, it is necessary that both states would make a joint decision on this issue and naturally would fund it jointly, too.

Question N 15 [time=18.09.2007 13:59:48(MSK)] [from Nino Narimanashvili, The Samkhret Karibche; Irakli Chikhladze, a free-lance reporter; Elza Tsiklauri, The Rezonansi (Georgia)]
How did the Russian economic blockade against Georgia affect the Armenian economy? Didn’t this fact affect the attitude of the political circles of Armenia with regard to strategic cooperation with Russia?

Answer [time:18.09.2007 15:10:16(MSK)]
Specifically our party has publicly spoken of this problem, for some of the economic steps of Russia undertaken against Georgia, did have as much negative influence on Armenia as they had on Georgia, something that does not come from the principles of strategic partnership. From this perspective, it can be stated that the right application of the Armenian and Russian strategic partnership may be considered a stabilizing factor for the region as a whole.

Question N 16 [time=18.09.2007 14:00:13(MSK)] [from Shirinyan A.A. (Armenia)]
Hetq On-line. The other day the issue of building a correctional facility in Samtskhe-Javakheti was raised in the Armenian Parliament. Opinions differed in the Parliament. What is your opinion on this?

Answer [time:18.09.2007 15:27:52(MSK)]
The program of turning Samtskhe-Javakheti a place of detention is not new. Such a program used to exist still under President Gamsakhurdia when the inmates of Georgian prisons had an opportunity to leave for Samtskhe-Javakheti with limited possibility of moving around instead of spending the whole sentence term in prison. It seems (though the leader of the Armenian church in Georgia does not share this opinion) that the construction of a new prison pursues the purpose of changing the demographic situation in this region. The construction of a prison for 2 – 3 thousand inmates envisages the presence and residence in the region of at least as many support personnel, which serves as a basis for such concerns. A similar concern is brought about by the construction for the purpose of the extension of the orphanage in Ninotsminda, which is an orphanage where children from all over Georgia are brought to live. Of course, one may respond that all this is directed towards the improvement of the social and economic situation of the residents of the region, since, for example, they will provide the prison with food and so on, but in this case the authorities should have spoken and consulted the local people for them not to treat such undertakings with suspicion and fear.

Question N 17 [time=18.09.2007 14:03:51(MSK)] [from Anvar Ursoy, reporter (Azerbaijan)]
Hello, Mr. Manoyan! Why couldn’t your party win in the Parliamentary elections?

Answer [time:18.09.2007 15:33:45(MSK)]
Two reports from Azerbaijan asked one and the same question, that is why I will answer both of them at once. The political power that won in the Parliamentary elections made use of all its resources, including the administrative ones. Secondly, the influence of the propaganda against our party led during the Soviet times and in the times of the former President of the RA can still be felt among the population. There remains only to note that the popularity of the Dashnaktsutyun Party among the population is increasing from election to election.

Question N 18 [time=18.09.2007 14:08:22(MSK)] [from Shoshiashvili M.N. (Georgia)]
Mr. Manoyan. On behalf of the present Georgian reporters and the reporters from the Caucasus Institute for Peace, Democracy and Development, I thank you for your cooperation and sincerity.

Answer [time:18.09.2007 15:35:52(MSK)]
I also thank all the reporters. And I think that the role of mass media is great in our region in establishing mutual trust, and I hope that this interview will serve that purpose, too.

Question N 19 [time=18.09.2007 14:15:08(MSK)] [from Arzu Aliyeva, Radio reporter (Azerbaijan)]
Hello, Mr. Manoyan! Why couldn’t your party win in the Parliamentary elections?

Answer [time:(MSK)]

About  Memorandum
Login: 
Password: 
Registration
Articles market
Offers of Journalists:
Offers of publishers:

...
"AZG"
...
Hetq-online
...

...

...
Announcement
Questions are accepted only from the registered journalists
Last Online Interviews
Stepan Eranosian
Manoyan Giro, Armenia
Mindiashvili Beka, Georgia
Interviews archive
A B C D E F J H I J K L M
N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

South Caucasus: Legal advice

Advicer:Rshtuni Narine (Armenia)
Questions & answers
Advicer:Hadjibeyli Annagi Bahadur oglu
Questions & answers


The website is created with the EURASIA Foundation support With the assistance of the European Union the CIPDD implements the project Independent Media for Civil Integration. The project is carried out using the Caucasus Journalists Network capacity.

Design and hosting — «Contact Company», Dubna.